Friday, 20 November 2026

A perennial favourite: 1st Battle of Bull Run

I invited my new wargaming comrade Martyn over to christen my newly set up war room. He asked that we play the first battle of the American Civil War: the 1st Battle of Bull Run.

I must have played this a good half a dozen times. It seems perennially popular. Back in February, I wrote an essay on "Why do some battles become favourites?". In the case of Bull Run, it ticks all the boxes I offered as reasons:

1. Epic History! Well, it's the curtain-raiser for an epic war, and it has some epic episodes.

2. Great Generals! Maybe not many so great on the day, but we get an early glimpse of names that will become famous (or infamous): Jackson, JEB Stuart, Sherman, Burnside, etc.

3. The Battlefield! Places like Henry Hill and Matthews Hill are etched in history.

4. The Armies! A colourful array of units in their pretty early-war uniforms (e.g., Wheat's Tigers), before everyone has been reduced to drab sameness.

5. The Drama! "There is Jackson standing like a stone wall!"

It also measures up as a game. There is plenty of movement and action, and with two inexperienced armies involved it is quite unpredictable and therefore exciting.

Here's a photo-heavy (20+), caption-light report of our game, followed by Reflections at the end.

The battlefield, looking west from the Confederate table edge. Bull Run is the river on the right. Red counters mark the Objectives: the town of Newmarket (bottom left); Bald Hill and Henry Hill (upper left and centre); the Stone Bridge (right centre) and Ball's Ford (bottom right). Only half the Confederate force is on-table initially: Bartow and Bee's brigades marching up the road left of pic; Evans's brigade just visible on Matthews Hill (top centre); and Cocke's guarding Ball's Ford.

Wheeling right to look north beyond the Stone Bridge, we see Schenck's brigade screening the rest of Tyler's US 1st Division. Martyn has opted to have these march west to join the US main body, rather than wait until the dice say Tyler is brave enough to try to force a crossing at the Stone Bridge. (There's a scenario rule restricting Tyler's movement for the first few turns.)

The US main body all arrives via the road just west of Matthews Hill (top of pic). Hunter's US 2nd Division enters on Turn 1, two brigades of Heintzelman's 3rd Division on Turn 2, and the last brigade on Turn 3.
Figures are Baccus 6mm.

My Rebs have moved faster than Martyn's Yankees and should be able to occupy the Objective hills in time to defend them.

Martyn therefore decides not to rush straight up but shifts his leading brigades to the right to leave space for the following units to form a strong line.

Sherman and Keyes ford Bull Run. It will take them a little while to do this and to get through the woods above the ford. Meanwhile, their artillery is seduced by a tempting vantage point in the NW corner of the battlefield, but will find there are no targets in range by the time it gets there.

Different view of the same formations. From this direction, we can just see Evans's Rebs on Matthews Hill.

The US starts to form its battle line in front of Bald Hill (left) and Henry Hill (right). The US batteries have deployed some distance away.

As the US patiently develops for the attack, Jackson's brigade (centre right of pic) races up into the gap on the right of Henry Hill. This is the best formation on the battlefield today, rated Trained when almost everyone else is Raw and Fragile.

A turn later, Jackson has slotted in on Bartow's right. The Union boys have yet to venture across the stream along the Confederate front. Lower right, Cocke is emboldened to cross Bull Run and make sure Schenck doesn't sneak onto one of the Objective bridges.

Battle is joined! US assaults are shaping up against the two Objective hills. Top right, Evans has come down from Matthews Hill to bite the tail of the arriving Yankee column. He has disrupted a US brigade (white puff) but at the cost of going Low on Ammo (brown puff). Centre right, Jackson has formed up to assault the US brigade in the woods there, which has managed to stop his attack with fire but likewise gone Low on Ammo. 

Wider view of the US half of the same turn shows Schenck still unmoved (lower right) but the rest of Tyler's division about to trap Evans (top centre and right).

The first US assault on Bald Hill has been a disaster. One US brigade has retired Spent (black puff) to the top left corner and will play no further part. On Henry Hill, the US is winning the firefight.

Turn 6 and the rest of the Confederate force finally arrives. Kirby-Smith races up the road to reinforce the hill line (left), while two substantial brigades (foreground) move towards the gap on Jackson's right. But will they be in time to deny Sherman's column (top right) the Stone Bridge (right edge)?

Cocke guards the northern end of the Stone Bridge against Schenck.

High drama as Willcox's brigade storms Bald Hill. By the wonders of modern technology, the Objective counter changes from Confederate red to Union blue. Can Bee and/or Kirby-Smith retake it?

Double trouble - Porter wipes out Bartow's Confederate brigade and Henry Hill falls to the US as well! Kirby-Smith has to divert his attention there.

JEB Stuart sees the threat to the Stone Bridge, so he dashes up with his tiny cavalry unit to distract Sherman's column.

Bee counterattacks on Bald Hill but will be repulsed.

Early (right of pic) arrives and prepares to join Kirby-Smith in an attempt to retake Henry Hill.

JEB Stuart's delaying action has bought just enough time for Bonham to protect the Stone Bridge from Sherman. Sherman charges and pushes Bonham back, but not enough to take the Stone Bridge.

That failure meant the US fell just short of what it needed for a draw or victory, so we did not need to play out the final Confederate turn. A win for Dixie! But given that this was only Martyn's second or third BBB game as against my 200 or so, he and his Yankees performed creditably so I will let him keep his sword.

Reflections

Knowing too much history? One reason Martyn asked to fight this was because he knows the history of the battle. This made him very conscious of the importance of the fight for Matthews Hill. However, Matthews Hill is not an Objective in scenario terms. Its importance comes from the fact that Evans's Confederates there can be a thorn in the side of the US units trying to reach and take the actual Objectives. Certainly Evans kept a few of Martyn's units busy long enough to make a difference in our game, despite Martyn having read the scenario brief that warns against massing troops there.

Replay value. Another of my "Reflections" essays was on "Replaying scenarios: pros and cons". As I said, I've played this one a few times before. This game was different from any of the previous ones. Replay value confirmed.

Narrow margins of victory. At the end, this looked like a comfortable Confederate victory. However, it wouldn't have needed much to go differently for the US to come out with a draw or even a win. Martyn was shelling Cocke's brigade on my quiet right flank for several turns, with a 1/12 chance of killing a base and rendering the unit Spent. Had that happened, Schenck could well have taken the Stone Bridge or even Ball's Ford; and Sherman wouldn't have needed a huge amount of luck to take the Stone Bridge as well. Closer than it looked!




No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments welcome!